Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | horns4lyfe's commentslogin

And that’s why they love visa workers

There’s nothing remotely sensible about what Canada has done to allow Indian ethnic cartels to take over their job market


That’s not even remotely the case. We just don’t have enough people willing to move to rural Alaska.


I'm sure the supply will go up if extra $$$ is paid.


I really think y’all are underestimating the reality of living in rural Alaska. I wouldn’t take a job there unless I had literally no other livable options.


Except you'll have to spend way more than $100,000 to incentify US citizen from a city to move there and stay.

And they not gonna have the same near slave H1B conditions where changing their job is just impossible..

H1B workers in IT even have an option to find a new visa sponsor, but nobody needs foreign teacher with H1B in California or Texas or basically anywhere else.


I have to wonder if some kind of fly in fly out arrangement like is used for a lot of other jobs in undesirable locations would work. I've got a friend who's a nurse/paramedic in an indigenous community in the australian outback, and he works 6 weeks in the community with a per diem and company house, and then has 6 weeks to travel or live in Brisbane between stints. A school could do quarterly swaps of teachers, so there's a Q1/Q3 teacher and a Q2/Q4 teacher each working 9 weeks at a time.


$100K would certainly garner tons of prospects. Rural schools around me only pay $30K


Not sure Alaska with it's threadbare tax regime is going to do that.


...for the given price.


So your argument is we have to give American jobs to foreigners here in America or they’ll take them overseas? Pardon me if I’m not convinced


If people that think like you had actually done something about it, then we wouldn’t be to this point. But at this point the only people taking action are trumps, and if that’s the only solution being offered, it will be taken. The conversation here is mild, get the room temp on this issue outside of lib tech circles and you’ll see


So after 4 years, or whenever this con man finally has the decency to keel over, is everyone who supported these performative non-solutions simply to "be heard" (or however else they frame their emotional release) going to own up to the fact that they've burnt all the political capital on the issues they care about? Or are they going to blame their predictable failures on "libuhruls" and go right back to whinging while waiting for the next con man who might pay them lip service?


Is everyone just going to ignore that most of the jobs created in the post few years have gone to foreign born workers? Is it taboo, but some how the “Gen Z is dumb” is brought up multiple times in all its glorious stupidity


1. Is incredibly stupid and just a talking point used to bring in labor from overseas that is wage suppression at best and ethnic nepotism at worse. You mean to tell me the average college grad from India is better? Nonsense


I literally never made any comments or aspersions on the quality of US graduates relative to other countries; just the quality of graduates relative to the quality of graduates from the same university ten years prior, or at least employers' perceived quality of these candidates.


You mean to tell me the average college grad from every country is exactly the same?


Sales


We haven’t eliminated entry level positions, we decided it was better to import foreign labor than to train up new grads. Because we’re dumb, and in some cases tribal.


That's the opposite of tribal. If we were tribal we wouldn't be importing low skill people from India to fill our entry level positions.


The current interview process isn’t meant to get the best talent, its intention is to give managers on visas an easy way to bring in other visa workers (via sharing questions and scaling difficulty for no-visa applicants)


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: