Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Why do people vote for large, strong governments that are able to take the power you suggest Tech is enabling them to take?
 help



It's starting to feel like ethno-nationalism is the answer.

See: the PRC. Support for surveillance is allegedly high. Anecdotally, talking to PRC citizens in circumstances where they don't need to worry about said surveillance (e.g., when they're vacationing in Japan and I want to pester someone and practice my mandarin), they generally like it. Makes them feel safe.

The CPC has sold them on a vision of them as members of the state-race "Chinese" (which is not really an ethnicity any more than "American" is) and the surveillance as a thing that keeps them and their "Chinese" lifestyle safe from non-Chinese. Uighurs have to be extra surveilled until they're also Chinese, which, many are now according to the CPC.

So PRC citizens feel safe and cozy among in the country for "their people," not realizing this whole ethnonationalist concept is at best 100 years old, maybe even younger. During the Qing dynasty, there's a whole hell of a lot of people that think of themselves as "Chinese" that definitely weren't by the dynastic government.

I smell similar happening in Russia, the USA, and Israel, with State support. It looks like right wing groups are trying to pull it off in the UK and Germany as well.


>Anecdotally, talking to PRC citizens in circumstances where they don't need to worry about said surveillance (e.g., when they're vacationing in Japan and I want to pester someone and practice my mandarin)

I'm not sure you are aware that China has monitoring operations for its citizens outside China.


> I'm not sure you are aware that China has monitoring operations for its citizens outside China.

Sure, you and I know that, but most PRC people don't really believe in that or are aware. At least nobody I've met.


have successfully pulled* it off in the UK and Germany



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: